Forums > Muse Polls > Poll: Survival vs CE - READ FIRST YO

 


Survival (79)
Citizen Erased (88)
You can vote by clicking a line above.

Caville

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


13306 posts

- Callville Bay



Exp - 14306


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 12:15 GMT | #2306803 |   | Split
Plug in Baby will stay, the rest will go.

Survival has tons more artistic quality than Citizen Erased, yet, people don't see that.


|03.08.06|12.04.08|04.09.09|04.10.09|12.11.09|04.09.10|11.09.10|28.08.11| 01.11.12 | 26.05.13 |
YouTube|@Caville

ewok

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


787 posts

-



Exp - 4492


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 13:11 GMT | #2306813 |   | Split
Quote
name :
I`m convinced there is no argument and the whole thing is an elaborate troll by half the users.

Screw this. If someone doesn`t repost a working link I`m voting anyway.


The link, when it works, would send you back to this thread.

That's the first time I've seen the phrase "elaborate troll," and with rather proper timing.


drummerboy5

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


1013 posts

-



Exp - 3670


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 13:40 GMT | #2306819 |   | Split
Quote
Caville :
Plug in Baby will stay, the rest will go.

Survival has tons more artistic quality than Citizen Erased, yet, people don't see that.



I can see that, but there's something different with Citizen Erased. The atmosphere of the song. I can't exactly put it into words but there's something really appealing in the music of Citizen Erased.


The slime looks so good on your face. One for charm, one for disgrace. Cunt.

Last.fm | Tumblr

Caville

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


13306 posts

- Callville Bay



Exp - 14306


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 14:03 GMT | #2306825 |   | Split
Quote
ewok :
Quote
name :
I`m convinced there is no argument and the whole thing is an elaborate troll by half the users.

Screw this. If someone doesn`t repost a working link I`m voting anyway.


The link, when it works, would send you back to this thread.

That's the first time I've seen the phrase "elaborate troll," and with rather proper timing.


Absolutely no troll. I just think Survival is the most well written piece of art I have heard from Muse. Fact.


|03.08.06|12.04.08|04.09.09|04.10.09|12.11.09|04.09.10|11.09.10|28.08.11| 01.11.12 | 26.05.13 |
YouTube|@Caville

ewok

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


787 posts

-



Exp - 4492


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 15:03 GMT | #2306835 |   | Split
Quote
Caville :
Quote
ewok :
Quote
name :
I`m convinced there is no argument and the whole thing is an elaborate troll by half the users.

Screw this. If someone doesn`t repost a working link I`m voting anyway.


The link, when it works, would send you back to this thread.

That's the first time I've seen the phrase "elaborate troll," and with rather proper timing.


Absolutely no troll. I just think Survival is the most well written piece of art I have heard from Muse. Fact.


I don't think, actually, that "troll" is completely accurate. I apologize for that. However, it seems that quite a few voted Survival as a joke. I agree that it is very complex and well-written, but there's something different about Citizen Erased.


Caville

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


13306 posts

- Callville Bay



Exp - 14306


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 15:37 GMT | #2306844 |   | Split
Don't worry, everything I've said is a joke and this thread is a joke. Honestly.


|03.08.06|12.04.08|04.09.09|04.10.09|12.11.09|04.09.10|11.09.10|28.08.11| 01.11.12 | 26.05.13 |
YouTube|@Caville

paztopia

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


11767 posts

- Brussels



Exp - 12408


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 15:55 GMT | #2306852 |   | Split

meee

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2998 posts

- SL



Exp - 10078


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 16:56 GMT | #2306875 |   | Split
Quote
Caville :
Don't worry, everything I've said is a joke and this thread is a joke. Honestly.



it is, but jokes should be funny ...


IŽll hide from the world
Behind a broken frame
And IŽll burn forever canŽt face the shame!


... tired of living ...


* Rock For People - 5th July 2010 *

ewok

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


787 posts

-



Exp - 4492


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 17:53 GMT | #2306906 |   | Split
Quote
meee :
Quote
Caville :
Don't worry, everything I've said is a joke and this thread is a joke. Honestly.



it is, but jokes should be funny ...


They should be, but are they always?


meee

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2998 posts

- SL



Exp - 10078


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 18:40 GMT | #2306921 |   | Split
Quote
ewok :
Quote
meee :
Quote
Caville :
Don't worry, everything I've said is a joke and this thread is a joke. Honestly.



it is, but jokes should be funny ...


They should be, but are they always?



no ... like this poll


IŽll hide from the world
Behind a broken frame
And IŽll burn forever canŽt face the shame!


... tired of living ...


* Rock For People - 5th July 2010 *

Caville

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


13306 posts

- Callville Bay



Exp - 14306


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 20:19 GMT | #2306938 |   | Split
Some people find it funny, some people don't.


|03.08.06|12.04.08|04.09.09|04.10.09|12.11.09|04.09.10|11.09.10|28.08.11| 01.11.12 | 26.05.13 |
YouTube|@Caville

Stavros678

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


109 posts

-



Exp - 1101


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 20:24 GMT | #2306943 |   | Split
THIS POLL IS A RACE
IT'S A RACE!


Radiohead >>>> Muse

paztopia

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


11767 posts

- Brussels



Exp - 12408


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 20:25 GMT | #2306945 |   | Split
It is funny on quite a lot of levels.


Cheap DIY Kitchens @ pazfm

New_One

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2833 posts

- tg9fci85rv



Exp - 10365


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 21:31 GMT | #2306962 |   | Split
It's not funny.


YOU PAID FOR THE WHOLE SEAT BUT YOUŽLL ONLY NEED THE EDGE








Word say word son.


hey wow

pink_ego_200000

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


447 posts

- London



Exp - 6412


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 21:54 GMT | #2306966 |   | Split
I love CE however, really enjoy Survival. I've been a fan since Showbiz, and must admit there are plenty of other songs I like more than CE.

Its a clever song, but Live I reckon Survival will be brilliant!




Check out my Music!

www.jasonlakemusic.co.uk

karinallen

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


114 posts

- South Carolina



Exp - 2454


Report this post | 23 Jul 2012 23:20 GMT | #2306977 |   | Split
It's so funny it makes me wish I could vote for Survival twice.


Essentially, we approach music the same way Monty Python did comedy. ~Matt Bellamy

Stavros678

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


109 posts

-



Exp - 1101


Report this post | 24 Jul 2012 00:40 GMT | #2306981 |   | Split
Quote
karinallen :
It's so funny it makes me wish I could vote for Survival twice.



It's just soooo good


Radiohead >>>> Muse

08KerrIR43

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


533 posts

- horsham



Exp - 4532


Report this post | 24 Jul 2012 17:35 GMT | #2307125 |   | Split
this is just silly =P you get the people who actually want to vote for survival (10%) the people who just don't want to see CE in something again (10%) and people who are trolling (31%)


and well praaaaaaayy that theres no God, to punish ussss and maaake a fuss

09.11.2009 SECC Glasgow
12.11.2009 O2 London
09.07.2010 T in the Park
10.09.2010 Wembley
11.09.2010 Wembley
Reading Festival 2011
SECC 2012
Emerites 2013 x2

New_One

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2833 posts

- tg9fci85rv



Exp - 10365


Report this post | 24 Jul 2012 22:22 GMT | #2307227 |   | Split
Thats not whats going on at all.


YOU PAID FOR THE WHOLE SEAT BUT YOUŽLL ONLY NEED THE EDGE








Word say word son.


hey wow

paztopia

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


11767 posts

- Brussels



Exp - 12408


Report this post | 25 Jul 2012 00:05 GMT | #2307246 |   | Split
People just have to accept other peoples opinions, it's now got to the stage where people who like a song are trolls.
CE aint shit but clearly more people like survivy.


Cheap DIY Kitchens @ pazfm

name

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9500 posts

- Tokyo



Exp - 11516


Report this post | 25 Jul 2012 07:19 GMT | #2307274 |   | Split
Not funny.

I`m voting for Citizen Erased, "ironically".


...the fact that it been chosen makes me thing it`ll be pants and were getting NSC 2. - Me, about Survival.

Its not elitism, some people are just better than others. - Joe.

Twitter

Pib

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


14863 posts

- Pib



Exp - 12959


Report this post | 25 Jul 2012 10:47 GMT | #2307300 |   | Split
I didn't vote.

Non-conformist.

\m/



Listening to...
Tumblr...

Dingerbell

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


38 posts

- Leeds



Exp - 1181


Report this post | 19 Aug 2012 21:05 GMT | #2314579 |   | Split
Errr, what is happening here?!

Citizen Erased, clearly.

Not that Survival is bad, it's just not that good. The verse's and ending are poor- even though the solo's are pretty good.


Nitsuga

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


85 posts

-



Exp - 1098


Report this post | 20 Aug 2012 16:07 GMT | #2314684 |   | Split
OP: You're a genius. You deserve a medal. Yours is the most convincing argument I've read in a long time.

Edit: Oh, I didn't fall for it. I voted for Survival anyway, for obvious reasons.


holland

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2378 posts

- York



Exp - 7397


Report this post | 21 Aug 2012 15:46 GMT | #2316039 |   | Split
I can't tell who the Hell's being serious

Also why on Earth is my sig linking to amazon?


Sheffield Arena 18/11/06
Marlay Park 13/08/08
Sheffield Arena 04/11/09
Manchester Old Trafford Cricket Ground 04/09/10



Every forum post or comment is property of their respective contributor. Any upload of audio or video containing Muse is property of Muse (excludes covers/remixes which remain property of their respective producers). Bootlegs downloaded may not represent actual sound quality of Muse, regardless of the source of recording. We reserve the right to ban anyone from the website if they do not abide by the site rules.

View our privacy policy here



Powered by LDU 802