Oceansizer

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9994 posts

- Cunt



Exp - 11202


Report this post | 22 Feb 2012 16:11 GMT | #2275260 |   | Split
Quote
A priest God never paid :
I was pun-questioning Tom's lack of Explosions love.



They're a classic example of a very boring band getting acclaim purely because they're classed as post-rock.


A Liver A Lung A Kidney A Thumb
last.fm

A priest God neve...

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


4116 posts

- Twilight Galaxy



Exp - 8212


Report this post | 22 Feb 2012 16:44 GMT | #2275268 |   | Split
I don't base my preferences in music on acclaim. I started listening to them when I wanted something instrumental other than classical music to study with. They stuck and now have a calming effect on me in many a time of distress.

I'm not a post-rock expert so I don't know all of them and the amount of acclaim they get. I do recognize EitS's music is softer and more spun-out than most bands associated with them. Maybe that's where you get "boring" from, but I disagree.


Muselives top 100 of all time - edition 2011.
30/06/06 19/12/06 27/05/07 28/06/07 13/08/08 02/11/09 14/11/09 01/07/10 11/09/10 28/08/11
Last.fm

Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 22 Feb 2012 23:34 GMT | #2275339 |   | Split
Now entering top 10. I will post #6-10 now, but then afterwards only 1 album per post. So the top 5 should take almost a week to be revealed :P



#10 - 40 points - 5 votes

Elbow - Build A Rocket Boys!







#9 - 40 points - 6 votes

Arctic Monkeys - Suck It And See







#8 - 41 points - 5 votes

Kaizers Orchestra - Violeta Violeta (Vol I)







#7 - 44 points - 5 votes

Fleet Foxes - Helplessness Blues







#6 - 45 points - 6 votes

Foo Fighters - Wasting Light




08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

Oceansizer

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9994 posts

- Cunt



Exp - 11202


Report this post | 22 Feb 2012 23:37 GMT | #2275341 |   | Split
Fleet Foxes beaten by Foo fighters isn't great.

/whinging about the results when I haven't voted.


A Liver A Lung A Kidney A Thumb
last.fm

Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 23 Feb 2012 02:21 GMT | #2275371 |   | Split
You don't get to whinge then :P

Any guesses for a top 5? Anyone who guesses the correct 5 albums and in the correct order will receive a cookie somehow, somewhere, sometime...


08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

A priest God neve...

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


4116 posts

- Twilight Galaxy



Exp - 8212


Report this post | 23 Feb 2012 10:56 GMT | #2275415 |   | Split
I could go back and do the math... How yummie is the cookie?

Okay here goes nothing:

5. Steven Wilson
4. Coldplay
3. Radiohead
2. Bon Iver
1. The Antlers


Muselives top 100 of all time - edition 2011.
30/06/06 19/12/06 27/05/07 28/06/07 13/08/08 02/11/09 14/11/09 01/07/10 11/09/10 28/08/11
Last.fm

Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 23 Feb 2012 11:03 GMT | #2275417 |   | Split
Quote
A priest God never paid :
I could go back and do the math... How yummie is the cookie?


Well... That depends on a lot of things. I'm gonna refer to the somehow, somewhere, sometime-comment. It all depends on where you get it, when you get it and how you get it.


08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

Cross_Pollination

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2909 posts

- ull



Exp - 6591


Report this post | 23 Feb 2012 11:21 GMT | #2275419 |   | Split
Did Coldplay really get that many votes?


Sheffield Arena - 04/11/09
Wembley Stadium - 11/09/10

REAL FAN

Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 23 Feb 2012 21:49 GMT | #2275489 |   | Split
Quote
Cross_Pollination :
Did Coldplay really get that many votes?


Only time will tell. They're not be found on the 5th spot:


#5 - 47 points - 6 votes

Steven Wilson - Grace For Drowning




08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

deadstar666

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


8319 posts

- Ringwood



Exp - 9836


Report this post | 23 Feb 2012 23:10 GMT | #2275506 |   | Split
Coldplay, Antlers and Bon Iver were all either great or phenomenal. Radiohead was shit, as we all know. But I guess those will be the top 4.


13/11/09
11/09/10

last.fm

Oceansizer

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9994 posts

- Cunt



Exp - 11202


Report this post | 24 Feb 2012 00:19 GMT | #2275514 |   | Split
Love it if coldplay won.


A Liver A Lung A Kidney A Thumb
last.fm

meee

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


3128 posts

- SL



Exp - 10940


Report this post | 24 Feb 2012 11:16 GMT | #2275557 |   | Split
Quote
Oceansizer :
Love it if coldplay won.






I´ll hide from the world
Behind a broken frame
And I´ll burn forever can´t face the shame!


... tired of living ...


* Rock For People - 5th July 2010 *

Cross_Pollination

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2909 posts

- ull



Exp - 6591


Report this post | 24 Feb 2012 14:25 GMT | #2275590 |   | Split
Bon Iver ought to win


Sheffield Arena - 04/11/09
Wembley Stadium - 11/09/10

REAL FAN

A priest God neve...

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


4116 posts

- Twilight Galaxy



Exp - 8212


Report this post | 24 Feb 2012 14:48 GMT | #2275596 |   | Split
Quote
Tøe :
Quote
A priest God never paid :
I could go back and do the math... How yummie is the cookie?


Well... That depends on a lot of things. I'm gonna refer to the somehow, somewhere, sometime-comment. It all depends on where you get it, when you get it and how you get it.



Drenched in beer would be the obvious choice.


Muselives top 100 of all time - edition 2011.
30/06/06 19/12/06 27/05/07 28/06/07 13/08/08 02/11/09 14/11/09 01/07/10 11/09/10 28/08/11
Last.fm

Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 25 Feb 2012 05:42 GMT | #2275738 |   | Split
I can now announce that, as everyone has already guessed, the remaining artists are The Antlers, Bon Iver, Coldplay and Radiohead. Now question is in which order. I'll let you think about that and post #4 tomorrow

And Sean, a cookie drenched in beer does sound like a pretty good one!


08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

RandomJ

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2080 posts

- Manchester



Exp - 7395


Report this post | 25 Feb 2012 14:46 GMT | #2275779 |   | Split
Having a quick glance at the previous pages looks like a lot of people selected Coldplay so my guess is that will win. Shouldn't though easily their worst album.


Cross_Pollination

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2909 posts

- ull



Exp - 6591


Report this post | 25 Feb 2012 15:50 GMT | #2275785 |   | Split
Agreed with RandomJ. Mylo Xyloto is garbage, by far Coldplay's worst yet.


Sheffield Arena - 04/11/09
Wembley Stadium - 11/09/10

REAL FAN

Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 27 Feb 2012 01:17 GMT | #2276219 |   | Split
Quote
RandomJ :
Having a quick glance at the previous pages looks like a lot of people selected Coldplay so my guess is that will win. Shouldn't though easily their worst album.



I agree. But there's good news for you then

#4 - 51 points - 6 votes

Coldplay - Mylo Xyloto




08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

deadstar666

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


8319 posts

- Ringwood



Exp - 9836


Report this post | 27 Feb 2012 21:21 GMT | #2276330 |   | Split
I reckon it's joint third with X&Y, nowhere near as good as the first two though.


13/11/09
11/09/10

last.fm

Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 27 Feb 2012 23:20 GMT | #2276358 |   | Split
Quote
deadstar666 :
I reckon it's joint third with X&Y, nowhere near as good as the first two though.


imo X&Y is their best. Closely followed by the 2 old ones, then Viva La Vida... and then a huge jump to Mylo Xyloto


08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

RandomJ

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2080 posts

- Manchester



Exp - 7395


Report this post | 29 Feb 2012 23:58 GMT | #2276799 |   | Split
How long is this gonna take? Get on with it man!


Tøe

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7910 posts

- Brisbane, Australia



Exp - 12124


Report this post | 01 Mar 2012 00:23 GMT | #2276802 |   | Split
Quote
RandomJ :
How long is this gonna take? Get on with it man!


haha obviously a fair while... forgot about this. Well here comes number 3. I'll reveal number 1 and 2 in the same post as there's no point keeping number 1 secret after number 2's revealed.



Award for most unique votes goes to:

#3 - 59 points - 11 votes

Radiohead - The King of Limbs




Ps. I just bought ticket to see them about an hour ago.


08.07.07 - 24.10.07 - 26.10.09 - 03.07.10 - 10.09.10 - 11.09.10 - 05.12.10 - 06.12.10

Vote now in MLs Top Albums of All Time

deadstar666

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


8319 posts

- Ringwood



Exp - 9836


Report this post | 01 Mar 2012 17:09 GMT | #2276925 |   | Split
The fact that they have so many votes but near the bottom of lists implies that people only put it because they couldn't think of anything else. Which seems appropriate.


13/11/09
11/09/10

last.fm

Cross_Pollination

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2909 posts

- ull



Exp - 6591


Report this post | 01 Mar 2012 17:53 GMT | #2276938 |   | Split
Quote
deadstar666 :
I reckon it's joint third with X&Y, nowhere near as good as the first two though.



If you think MX and X&Y are their third best, I don't think I wanna know your least favourite. Parachutes, A Rush of Blood and Viva la Vida are above and beyond those two albums in every possible way imo


Sheffield Arena - 04/11/09
Wembley Stadium - 11/09/10

REAL FAN

meee

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


3128 posts

- SL



Exp - 10940


Report this post | 01 Mar 2012 19:43 GMT | #2276957 |   | Split
Quote
deadstar666 :
The fact that they have so many votes but near the bottom of lists implies that people only put it because they couldn't think of anything else. Which seems appropriate.






I´ll hide from the world
Behind a broken frame
And I´ll burn forever can´t face the shame!


... tired of living ...


* Rock For People - 5th July 2010 *



Every forum post or comment is property of their respective contributor. Any upload of audio or video containing Muse is property of Muse (excludes covers/remixes which remain property of their respective producers). Bootlegs downloaded may not represent actual sound quality of Muse, regardless of the source of recording. We reserve the right to ban anyone from the website if they do not abide by the site rules.

View our privacy policy here



Powered by LDU 802