Forums > The Polls Forum > Poll: Battlefield 3 vs MW3

 


Battlefield 3 (59)
Modern Warfare 3 (49)
You can vote by clicking a line above.

Pib

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


14839 posts

- Pib



Exp - 12959


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 12:47 GMT | #2229230 |   | Split
It reminds me of the old rivalry between Fifa and PES fans. Only somehow a bit more stupid. Like everyone needs validation for their decision of which game to buy by badmouthing the other one.



Listening to...
Tumblr...

musefansam2

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


5759 posts

- Manchester



Exp - 11836


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 13:43 GMT | #2229242 |   | Split
For people saying "sales" represent how good/bad a game is; i think your wrong.

For example, Shenmue 1 and 2 are two of the best games i've ever played and anyone who has played them will agree their brilliant, however they never did fuck all in sales.

The Bouncer; another quality game but never took off.


Earls Court London 20.12.04
Manchester Arena MEN 10.11.06
Echo Arena Liverpool 05.11.09
LCCC Manchester 04.09.10
Manchester Arena MEN 01.11.12
Emirates Stadium London 25&26.05.13
Etihad Stadium Manchester 01.06.13

ML101

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


110 posts

- Bay Area, Cali



Exp - 1500


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 15:42 GMT | #2229261 |   | Split

Sitting On Deadwood

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


2566 posts

- Ill Write You



Exp - 7379


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 16:04 GMT | #2229265 |   | Split
Oh my... It just looks so stunning.

Excuse me while I pick my jaw off of the floor.


Do, dooo, dododo

Welshlass

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


8609 posts

- Iddyland



Exp - 10174


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 16:23 GMT | #2229269 |   | Split
Quote
ML101 :
more gameplay footage! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8S_eEv_A5k&feature=channel_video_title



Dear fucking lord, it makes CoD look like Lego.


Last Fm

If you resort to giving up smoking, drinking and loving, you dont actually live longer - it just seems it

Caville

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


13300 posts

- Callville Bay



Exp - 14248


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 16:32 GMT | #2229272 |   | Split
Now, who said CoD is going to be the better game...? Lol@U


|03.08.06|12.04.08|04.09.09|04.10.09|12.11.09|04.09.10|11.09.10|28.08.11| 01.11.12 | 26.05.13 |
YouTube|@Caville

Sephian

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9018 posts

- Subtractingbeef



Exp - 12747


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 16:39 GMT | #2229275 |   | Split
I think there's something I'm not getting. I watched that and it just looked like Battlefield 2 with better graphics. And graphics are one of the least important things in a game. Fail to see why there's all this excitement.


Youtube
Soundcloud

Cogs and levers mesh
We are bound in death
Melt the silver down
Im still inside you
ಠ_ಠ

Musefan1991

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


4513 posts

- Chicago



Exp - 8789


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 17:13 GMT | #2229283 |   | Split
Quote
no-name :
Quote
Musefan1991 :
and i just realized theres more than one type of battlefield, to clarify, all my crap talking is towards the bad company series.



But I thought you'd played the older ones? You lambasted Caville because he hadn't played BF2.

Strange.



yeah older ones as in BF1 and BF2, which were bad company, it says on my game boxes, if that makes ay difference. its like the only ones ive seen for console anyways.

--------

and in that gameplay trailer, the maps look big as hell, that would be so annoying to play on, one of many reasons why i didnt get into the battlefield multiplayer. and this isnt the first time there has been graphics like that, Crysis 2 has already done this, so nothing new really.

the company took regular photos and remade them using thier cryengine 3 to show the amazing power of thier engine.

crysis vs real life


Facebook
soundcloud

AlexDalton123

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


4128 posts

- Watford



Exp - 7820


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 17:04 GMT | #2229285 |   | Split
Something can have the best graphics on the world, but also be the shittest thing ever.

I wont judge until I play them.



Take the pieces and build them skywards.


Manchester 06 - Wembley 07 - V Fest 08 - London 09 - Wembley 10 - Reading 11 - Manchester 12 - London 13 - London 13 - London 13
Facebook
@AlexDalto

ML101

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


110 posts

- Bay Area, Cali



Exp - 1500


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 17:17 GMT | #2229291 |   | Split
Quote
Sephian :
I think there's something I'm not getting. I watched that and it just looked like Battlefield 2 with better graphics. And graphics are one of the least important things in a game. Fail to see why there's all this excitement.



How is that a bad thing though Battlefield 2 came out in 2005, A lot of people loved it about time a proper sequel for the game came out the fans have been wanting it forever.


Sephian

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9018 posts

- Subtractingbeef



Exp - 12747


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 17:31 GMT | #2229294 |   | Split
Yeah I always prefer smaller maps.


Youtube
Soundcloud

Cogs and levers mesh
We are bound in death
Melt the silver down
Im still inside you
ಠ_ಠ

pluginsteve

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


4917 posts

- Essex



Exp - 8005


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 18:08 GMT | #2229309 |   | Split
I stand by original post by saying Gears of War 3 will be better.

Of course that's just my opinion and it's a third person shooter and not a first person shooter. I'll be off now.


Best Newbie in town, voted by YOU! - Muselive awards 2008.

Winner of the Services to Mankind, and Generally Being Awesome award - Muselive awards 2010.

jonodillieono

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


1625 posts

- Liverpool



Exp - 6547


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 18:23 GMT | #2229317 |   | Split
This^
On the "COD is better because it's sold more" argument.
Black Ops sold more than COD4 and COD4 is clearly a better game so that argument is invalid.


LOL

musefansam2

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


5759 posts

- Manchester



Exp - 11836


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 19:37 GMT | #2229330 |   | Split
Quote
Welshlass :
Quote
ML101 :
more gameplay footage! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8S_eEv_A5k&feature=channel_video_title



Dear fucking lord, it makes CoD look like Lego.



+1


Earls Court London 20.12.04
Manchester Arena MEN 10.11.06
Echo Arena Liverpool 05.11.09
LCCC Manchester 04.09.10
Manchester Arena MEN 01.11.12
Emirates Stadium London 25&26.05.13
Etihad Stadium Manchester 01.06.13

bellamy29

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


1419 posts

-



Exp - 5454


Report this post | 16 Aug 2011 20:40 GMT | #2229346 |   | Split
Quote
Pib :
How ridiculous the arguments between Battlefield and Modern Warfare fans are is never more evident than when they're arguing about which game is better before either have actually played the games.



Can't speak for everyone but I'm in the Battlefield 3 beta and have been for a while, playing it frequently.

MW3 looks like the same shit as MW2.


10.4.1 - Pacific Coliseum
13.2.6 - Rogers Arena

Sephian

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9018 posts

- Subtractingbeef



Exp - 12747


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 00:48 GMT | #2229412 |   | Split
Quote
ML101 :
Quote
Sephian :
I think there's something I'm not getting. I watched that and it just looked like Battlefield 2 with better graphics. And graphics are one of the least important things in a game. Fail to see why there's all this excitement.



How is that a bad thing though Battlefield 2 came out in 2005, A lot of people loved it about time a proper sequel for the game came out the fans have been wanting it forever.


I know but it seems like the same people who are praising Battlefield 3, despite the fact it doesn't really look any different, are the same people who are dissing Call of Duty, for not being any different. Does not compute in my head.

Anyway, I'm sure I will get both the games and probably love them both. I'll probably like Call of Duty more though, because I prefer small to medium size maps.


Youtube
Soundcloud

Cogs and levers mesh
We are bound in death
Melt the silver down
Im still inside you
ಠ_ಠ

Caville

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


13300 posts

- Callville Bay



Exp - 14248


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 00:57 GMT | #2229416 |   | Split
Battlefield 3 is very, very different to BC2...


|03.08.06|12.04.08|04.09.09|04.10.09|12.11.09|04.09.10|11.09.10|28.08.11| 01.11.12 | 26.05.13 |
YouTube|@Caville

Oceansizer

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9560 posts

- Cunt



Exp - 10818


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 11:22 GMT | #2229522 |   | Split
I'm buying BF3 because COD doesn't have a bowel-trembling bassline in the soundtrack.


A Liver A Lung A Kidney A Thumb
last.fm

DorDor

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


6114 posts

- Sthlm



Exp - 8034


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 11:42 GMT | #2229527 |   | Split
I love the CoD gameplay, it has been undefeatable for me since CoD2, something about it gives me such a lovely feeling, making every single kill giving you a rush of joy and excitement. At least this is me.

Also, I play games because of the campaigns. Sure, CoD's campaigns tend to be short, but their intense, epic and cinematic. I mean, some of the coolest and most unexpected game moments I have had is with CoD. Remember the MW Nuke?


Hodor, hodor hodor hodor. Hodor hodor? - Hodor

pluginsteve

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


4917 posts

- Essex



Exp - 8005


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 14:44 GMT | #2229583 |   | Split
How different will Battlefield 3 be to Bad Company 2? I didn't really like it that much nor was I good at it.

I also agree with Teo, Call of Duty have some very good moments in their campaign's.


Best Newbie in town, voted by YOU! - Muselive awards 2008.

Winner of the Services to Mankind, and Generally Being Awesome award - Muselive awards 2010.

Fritz92

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7481 posts

- Ponyville



Exp - 10606


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 14:46 GMT | #2229584 |   | Split
Quote
DorDor :
I love the CoD gameplay, it has been undefeatable for me since CoD2, something about it gives me such a lovely feeling, making every single kill giving you a rush of joy and excitement. At least this is me.

Also, I play games because of the campaigns. Sure, CoD's campaigns tend to be short, but their intense, epic and cinematic. I mean, some of the coolest and most unexpected game moments I have had is with CoD. Remember the MW Nuke?



One of my favourite game moments ever.


...And then I said; Oatmeal, are you CRAZY?!


Last.fm

Bass covers!

Pib

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


14839 posts

- Pib



Exp - 12959


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 15:05 GMT | #2229589 |   | Split
Yeah. The Call of Duty campaigns have been quite good recently. Modern Warfare was far and away the best as it kept the right balance between action movie cliche and genuinely exhilerating set pieces. Later games have upped the set piece ante, but sometimes less is more, and in this case they become a little overkill.

Modern Warfare had the arse droppingly awesome nuke sequence, which they obviously looked at, and tried to replicate a dozen times in Modern Warfare 2. All it does it dilute the appeal of these moments. Black Ops the same.

Battlefield has never had a particularly good campaign, I think. I realise that a lot of people only want the online and couldn't care less about the campaign, but it's still part of the game.



Listening to...
Tumblr...

Fritz92

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


7481 posts

- Ponyville



Exp - 10606


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 15:25 GMT | #2229601 |   | Split
Honestly I care a lot more about the single player experience than multiplayer when it comes to these games. And yeah, I didn't like the campaign in MW2 anywhere near as much as the one in the first game. It was as if they were trying to replicate all the same "Wow! Surprise"-moments from the first game, but more over the top, which both ruined the surprise and made them be a bit "too much".

Getting to see the last moments of the american character in MW as he draws his last breath after the nuke was amazing. Getting to see the last of moment of the random american astronaut as the EMP blows up in MW2 was pretty meh, in my opinion. It looked cool, but nowhere near as emotional.


...And then I said; Oatmeal, are you CRAZY?!


Last.fm

Bass covers!

Caville

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


13300 posts

- Callville Bay



Exp - 14248


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 15:26 GMT | #2229602 |   | Split
I bought Battlefield BC2 for the multiplayer, and I haven't even touched the single player yet.


|03.08.06|12.04.08|04.09.09|04.10.09|12.11.09|04.09.10|11.09.10|28.08.11| 01.11.12 | 26.05.13 |
YouTube|@Caville

Oceansizer

Online status Send a PM to this poster.


9560 posts

- Cunt



Exp - 10818


Report this post | 17 Aug 2011 15:34 GMT | #2229605 |   | Split
Then you're a willy.


A Liver A Lung A Kidney A Thumb
last.fm



Every forum post or comment is property of their respective contributor. Any upload of audio or video containing Muse is property of Muse (excludes covers/remixes which remain property of their respective producers). Bootlegs downloaded may not represent actual sound quality of Muse, regardless of the source of recording. We reserve the right to ban anyone from the website if they do not abide by the site rules.

View our privacy policy here



Powered by LDU 802